I don’t know..
I think Caulfield relates much of what Salinger believes himself. But as this is too much of a high standart (to use your quote) to live by, he prefers to leave it all together. Hopefully temporarily so for himself, seems not so for his creator.
An unreliable narrator should give you the sense that what he believes and feels subjectively is not so in the reality of the story. Did you get that feeling in The Catcher? I did not. I got the feeling that all the phony, superficial unpleasant characters that Caulfield describes are really so and the question is – what do you choose to do about it. By the way I know an excellent short story that portrays a REAL unreliable narrator. It’s called: “My Side of the Matter” and it’s by Truman Capote.
I don’t always agree with Wikipedia.
“Phony” religious red neck conservatives are only bigots if they assume that scholarly liberals are always wrong about everything. If they don’t assume that and ALWAYS judge and form their own opinios based on what they hear and see (and most definitely not on what they hear through the media) than how can they be bigots? I guess you get all kinds.. By the same token I guess that not all “open minded” liberal scholars are patronizing bigots but do you know what? I think that they tend to be more so because they will seldom question themselves or get scrutinized by others. Certainly no one will call them stupid – although in a lot of cases they are..
Oh well, I guess I have my own prejudices, like everyone else..
Oh please don’t read the Bible like a horror story. Suppose that someone would describe what’s going on in this day and age.. Has so much changed since those days? Turning children into ruthless war machines and so on.. Again I do believe that what is described there is basic human characteristics. By the way Elisha did some pretty good things too… I think that what happend to those children shows his greatness – what a great prophet he is. And yes by our standarts it sounds terrible but in an “eye for an eye”era.. And who’s to say what is better? Certainly it is less phony… And yes, those children were his enemies at that time. Children can do terrible things..
I know, I know, you don’t agree with me. Probably even shudder with horror at my insensitivity…How can I say that about little children, horrid as they may be, in the Biblical context as it is…Well, that’s the beauty of being able to speak one’s mind without fear of being labeled. And I wonder what I would find if being allowed to probe just a bit deeper into your inner soul.. Are there no prejudices, rigidity of thought, hate or fear lurking there? OK, maybe I’ve gone too far. Foregive me, I am really tired, It seems like I spent hours writing here.
Shall we agree to disagree?
Post Comments
lucyinthesky said – Tue, 03 Feb 2009 23:39:02 -0000
True enough! Hehe.